Watching the Toyota Pious advert just know I was struck by a thought (ok, doesn't happen often)
So the Pious is fuel efficient etc etc (though we know they're dirty to make and get rid of) but given the life and cost of the batteries is finite, and not that long at the moment, there will be virtually no 2nd hand value.
So, 5 years down the line, when you come to change your Pious to the latest and greatest lentil munching machine, who's going to want it? The cost of replacing the batteries will outweigh the value of the car. Therefore the only option will be to scrap it. I reckon manufacturers will offer some sort of buyback scheme in order to keep you brand-loyal, but the end result is scrapping.
How green is that? Currently, better engineered cars (Mercedes, BMW, Volvo... Toyota ) all attract reasonable 2nd hand prices, and surely as these cars have a 20 year or more lifespan, this is greener than crushing them and building a new one?
Given current (no pun intended) battery technology, these hybrids have a comparably very short life, which cannot be green by any stretch of the imagination. Therefore, why are we being encouraged to believe this type of car is the green option?
Oh, one day I'm sure it will be, but right now, it certainly is not.
So the Pious is fuel efficient etc etc (though we know they're dirty to make and get rid of) but given the life and cost of the batteries is finite, and not that long at the moment, there will be virtually no 2nd hand value.
So, 5 years down the line, when you come to change your Pious to the latest and greatest lentil munching machine, who's going to want it? The cost of replacing the batteries will outweigh the value of the car. Therefore the only option will be to scrap it. I reckon manufacturers will offer some sort of buyback scheme in order to keep you brand-loyal, but the end result is scrapping.
How green is that? Currently, better engineered cars (Mercedes, BMW, Volvo... Toyota ) all attract reasonable 2nd hand prices, and surely as these cars have a 20 year or more lifespan, this is greener than crushing them and building a new one?
Given current (no pun intended) battery technology, these hybrids have a comparably very short life, which cannot be green by any stretch of the imagination. Therefore, why are we being encouraged to believe this type of car is the green option?
Oh, one day I'm sure it will be, but right now, it certainly is not.
Comment